BeBook review
I like the digital life, computers – obviously – the web, blogs, streamed media, MP3s, digital TV and digital radio all feature. The last bastion of the analogue world is reading but for how much longer?
Well I’ve breached that bastion, having just purchased an eBook reader, naturally only after much research of the available models and their features. At the present time, that choice is somewhat limited.
Sony have a deal with Waterstones to sell their PRS 505 reader in-store for £199. According to a very reliable source, these are fantastically popular and are sold almost as soon as they arrive. Undeniably the Sony is good looking. It features both e-ink and e-paper technology found on all of the new readers, which brings a print like experience when viewing text on the LCD screen. Before I saw this in person, I was sceptical about the quality but trust me (I’m in IT) it is astonishingly clear, aesthetically pleasing and a joy to read -no back light to tire your eyes, no glare and crisp, zoom-able text.
I was offered a Sony with a generous £20 discount by my very reliable source, but I had to decline – I should have accepted and sold it on eBay where they are selling for more than the MRP due to high demand and low availability but that would have been too mercenary.
I didn’t take up this kind offer for the following reasons. The Sony forces you to purchase ebooks in their format and only from their website. Who wants to be tied down in that way? I’d also seen reviews that indicate there can be issues transferring ebooks onto the reader unless you use Windows. Mac users are just about tolerated but Sony doesn’t even know about us Linux folk. The range of other file formats it can use is limited, and there have been problems reported with PDFs. I’ve had past dealings with Sony’s customer support and found it to be almost non-existent, so not for me.
Another well known e-reader is Amazon’s Kindle. This is only available in the USA but will be coming to the UK and Europe in 2009. Amazon are currently securing deals with service providers. Like the Sony, the Kindle ties you to one source of bought eBooks – namely Amazon. Unlike the Sony it’s wi-fi enabled and allows you to subscribe to RSS and news feeds, for automatic updates. It’s not the most attractive looking thing on the plant, being made of white plastic and resembles a Fischer-Price toy. However, as I couldn’t buy it even if I wanted to, let’s move on.
IRex make a range of advanced readers. These feature wi-fi, touch sensitive screens, the ability to jot notes on your books and subscribe to news feeds. I don’t need those features. There are reports that their software is slow and over complicated. Add these negatives to the fact that their cheapest model comes in at just under £400, you can see why I didn’t give them much heed.
So that left two closely matched readers to consider, the BeBook and Cybook.
Both of these readers are of a similar size and appearance. They are not tied down to one particular ebook store and can connect easily to any computer (even one running Linux) appearing as a USB device. You can easily fit an SD card to extend storage and both have the same sized e-paper and e-ink screen as the Sony. So why of these two did I buy the BeBook?
It can read more document formats, it’s cheaper, it looks better (to my eye), it comes with a case and headphones (for listening to MP3s) as standard, it’s battery is easily replaced by the user and is readily available, it’s actually from a Nokia mobile phone – compare that with the Sony which has to be sent back if your battery dies. Having looked at YouTube reviews of both, the BeBook seemed faster in operation, specifically when turning pages.
The battery’s charge, they say is good to last 7,000 page turns. The BeBook only uses power to redraw or turn the page. That’s why it’s actually better to leave it on with the keys locked rather than waste power turning it off and on. There is also no chance of screen burn in with e-ink and e-paper.
It’s Linux based and Endless Ideas BV the software developers actively take on board customers’ suggestions for improving and extending the firmware. Their website has a helpful forum and thousands of e-Books ready for downloading for free. Simply put the BeBook is the best value and most extensible reader you can buy at the moment.
So having made my purchase, how is it in use? There is a one word answer – great!
The e-paper and e-ink produce a lovely reading experience. The reader is not heavy to hold, although I mostly keep it in its case so that I have the familiar two hands hold much like a book. The page turning is quicker than I thought it would be and after a while you don’t notice any lag, you just read. It is slower to redraw a page than it is to turn a page in a book but you soon adjust and press the button a line or two before you reach the bottom of the page.
There are two sets of page turning buttons. One at the bottom right hand corner of the BeBook and the other two on the left edge. The latter pair seem to be the wrong way round. The top one turns forward and the bottom goes back. This seems the wrong way round to me, as you have to “stretch” to reach the forward button. This is a very minor niggle and solved by using the buttons at the bottom of the reader.
The software permits speedy navigation around your library and within books. I use a 2GB SD card to store all my documents. I can create and name folders as I like on the card using my computer and these replicate on the BeBook. This allows me to store things as I want them, which is especially useful when one considers just how much material you can store on a 2GB card. I have 130 plays and novels, 10 Linux reference books and a further 10 manuals for computer hardware and my digital camera all taking up less than 300MB.
Another very handy navigational aid is the recent book list, which shows the last 8 documents you have read. This makes dipping in and out of books so easy. The BeBook also remembers where you are in each of your recent books and takes you straight there. If you want you can also assign up to 5 bookmarks per document. At the moment I’m reading Alice in Wonderland, a collection of Saki’s short stories and Charles Darwin’s Origin of Species. All of these were downloaded free from the BeBook site in optimised PDF format.
This brings me onto the subject of file formats. Here’s the official list of file types it can handle: pdf, mobi, prc, epub, lit, txt, fb2, doc, html, rtf, djvu, wol, ppt, mbp, chm, bmp jpg, png, gif, tif, rar, zip, mp3. Even I don’t know what some of these are.
So far I’ve tested PDFs, rtf, doc, txt and html. I’ve not bothered trying MP3s – I have an iPod for those. I loaded a JPEG or two but they were not outstanding although diagrams are fine. PDFs which have been optimised for the screen size of the BeBook and not for A4 are excellent. Unoptimised PDFs appear very small on the screen. Using the dimensions from the BeBook website, I was able to create good looking, optimised PDFs from Writer in OpenOffice.
I also found rtf files to look good. Docs and HTML were okay, although it was a shame not to see a Linux based and open device, not being able to read ODT files natively, although this is not too much of a problem as they OpenOffice can convert to PDF or rtf.
So formatting is not a problem, file transfer is speedy using an SD card, what then can you find to read?
The only closed format the BeBook can read at the moment is Mobi book. E-books in this format are available from a number of on-line book sellers. I’ve not yet bought one but I’ve downloaded samples and they worked well. Not all new books are available in an eBook format. Those that are cost nearly as much as the printed version. There really is no excuse for this, given the lack of printing, the saving of paper and non-existent transport costs. Once e-books become more popular and prevalent they are bound to become less expensive.
There are countless out of copyright books freely available from the web. As this includes the works of such people as Darwin, Dickens, Shakespeare, Saki, Lewis Carroll, Pope, Blake and many many more, I will not be short of reading material for a while. I’ve also added personal documents and manuals. Be warned though, if you do put anything personal on your SD card or BeBook take care as there is no password protection or locking ability.
Many people as yet cannot see the point of an e-reader. They are still comparatively expensive, you can buy a lot of books for £200. Many people comment on the physical pleasure of reading a book and also like the sense of ownership of building up a library. Agreed, but the ability to take a large number of books with you in one device will certainly appeal to students, commuters, travellers and technicians. A student of English Literature, for example could download for free and carry their entire coursework in one device.
I’m enjoying it and enjoying reading once again.
Tags: BeBook, Tech Stuff
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.







October 28th, 2008 at 7:33 am
I did just like you and compared features and prices before ordering my Bebook. I’m very happy with it, but I also have issues with the buttons. The page turning buttons are too small, the buttons to turn to next page, which you will use 95% of the time should be as big as the OK-button. I suspect that the small pageturning buttons will wear out long before the Bebook stop working.
If you like me read SciFi there are thousands of books available on filesharing hubs using DC++. I prefer to read books that come in Microsofts .lit format made for the MS Redaer which I’m using on my computer.
October 28th, 2008 at 10:52 am
Hi Jan,
Thanks for your comments. The BeBook is a great piece of kit!
The page turning buttons are a wee bit small but so far they have not caused me any issues, apart from the ones on the side being “the wrong way round.”
As a Linux user, I’ve not tried the MS .lit format but it does seem popular. I’ll have a look for Sci-Fi books which I do like – it’s been a while but the last ones I read were Frank Herbert’s Dune series.
Good luck!
November 3rd, 2008 at 10:54 am
Great piece of kit!
I’ve had a BeBook for a few weeks now and it’s great. There are still some refinements to be done with things like the Mobipocket reader implementation, but BeBook have been pretty repsonsive so far to user suggestions and requests, so I’m confident we’ll see even more imporvements in the near future firmware releases.
The device is really easy to use, and is great to read – I’ve already loaded it up with hundreds of books, so I’m ready for travel at a moments notice confident I have a heap of books with me, as well as work documents (PDF), manuals, etc.
Enjoy
November 3rd, 2008 at 11:12 pm
Orwell thanks for leaving a comment – you’re right they are great devices.
You will, I hope understand, but I have removed your e-mail address offering a discount code. While this is a great way of making a saving on a BeBook, and one which I took advantage of from another re-seller, this blog is personal, it’s mine and in my view there is enough advertising in the world.
November 6th, 2008 at 11:15 am
It’s claimed that the BeBook has a key that will detect if you are trying to read a copyright protected book even if they copyright protection has been removed. Do you know if this is so?
November 6th, 2008 at 12:26 pm
Hi Adam,
I’m not sure about that, not having put any “de-copyrighted” material on my BeBook.
I suspect the BeBook would simply not display anything it could not read, but this may depend on the original and end file formats selected and your method of “de-copyrighting.”
It’s not like an iPod, connected to a central library with DRM controls.
Good luck.
November 7th, 2008 at 1:07 am
Thanks for the reply. I don’t mind admitting I have thousands of ebooks in pdf and .lit format downloaded from torrents but I want to know if they will actually work on the BeBook before I go ahead and buy one.
November 7th, 2008 at 5:05 am
Adam, they all work fine without any problems.
November 7th, 2008 at 11:15 am
How exciting. What a great review page and follow up comments. I have been looking at buying an ereader for some time and keep delaying my decision. I am really keen on the idea of being able to take daily newspaper feeds. Without wi-fi this seems a bit of a faff but I take your point about the extra expense for this feature. Does anyone out there use the ebook to download daily news and if so how good is it?
November 7th, 2008 at 4:47 pm
I am becoming concerned that there are people making genuine, serious and inoffensive comments on this site. not a welcome development but I suppose I should accept change has ‘gotta come (in the words of an ancestor of the new president elect).
November 7th, 2008 at 5:11 pm
Perhaps people who read books and therefore show an interest in this sort of technology are just a polite tolerate subset of society. Having not spent much time on ipod/war game/porn blogs I don’t really know how people behave there – perhaps I don’t want to!
November 7th, 2008 at 6:36 pm
Simon, you will have to forgive DarkStar – he’s a regular contributor and therefore rather disturbed. Twenty years in the NHS has also not helped.
The wi-fi idea is nice if you regularly read newspapers for news – I don’t instead relying on Liferae for RSS feeds and news sites such as the BBC.
For me the BeBook is a chance to get away from a computer and read for the sake of it.
November 10th, 2008 at 10:02 am
I’m going to buy it today………
I will report back. Now you have explained the 25 years at the NHS I fully understand the challenges Darkstar must be facing….
I dropped ‘Exit Music’ in the bath last night and it went soggy. 24 hours drying out on the radiator and i will be back to reading the last of Rebus – I assume this technique will work fine with the Bebook…..
November 12th, 2008 at 5:12 pm
I’ve got one. It is very good. The nearly English manual is not much use and the navigation is a bit messy but for reading books it is great. I’m reading treasure Island – one of the 150 free books. Not all the pdf files I’ve downloaded come out well on the Bebook. I copied one from PDF to RTF but it loses its formatting. What we need is some optimising software – any volunteers?
November 12th, 2008 at 9:55 pm
Simon, congratulations on your purchase, they are a fun bit of kit – happy reading.
PDFs do need to be formatted for the BeBook screen and not A4 or letter size normally used for printing. Here are the correct margins and page size when printing to PDF.
There are I’m sure many text editors and formatters out there. The BeBook web site and forum will be useful and please remember that “Google is your friend.”
Good luck!
December 5th, 2008 at 8:48 pm
Hi Everyone,
Just wanted to say the BeBook is fantastic and well worth the money. I’ve had no trouble with their customer service and as has been mentioned the team from Endless Ideas seem really happy and eager to implement ideas to make it even better.
Cheers,
Adam
December 6th, 2008 at 1:28 am
Thanks Adam
Good to hear you have had no problems with the BeBook and are enjoying it.
I have amended your post to remove your e-mail address and link. I prefer not to allow advertising on my blog.
Good luck.
David
December 10th, 2008 at 6:47 pm
I just did a search on Stephen Fry’s blog to see whether he had an e-book reader. Well of course he does, he has three – but no BeBook – I think Endless Ideas should send him one for Christmas. See this post about Stephen’s blog.
December 16th, 2008 at 10:47 pm
Here’s a fun site extolling the features of the BeBook in the style of a BeBook.
December 22nd, 2008 at 4:41 pm
I have just updated my BeBeook’s firmware for the first time. This is a great way of providing users with the benefits of on-going development by Endless Ideas. This update provides better MobiPocket Book support for DRM’ed files as well as what on first glance appears to be a bit of a speed boost on page turns and moving around the menus.
The procedure for upgrading is pretty simple, with the only minor irritation being you have to use a 1GB SD card, as larger cards may or not work. These are becoming hard to find, but I sourced one on line especially for these updates.
The process is quick, taking me about 5 minutes. You should make sure your BeBook has a good charge and back up all your files on the BeBook in case of problems. As I retain all my books on a dedicated 2GB SD card – including the ones which come free with the device – I back up by removing the card.
You have to download the update, which is a compressed TAR file, then extract it and copy it to the root of your 1GB SD Card. You then power off the BeBook, insert the SD card and then press and hold the volume up button on the side of the reader while turning it back on.
The screen changes to say “Checking update file” at that point you can the release the volume button. The update begins, by updating the kernel, system, logo, parsers and other bits and pieces. These stages are shown on the screen in a numbered menu with a progress bar. At the successful conclusion of the update, the BeBook will beep several times and a message asking you to restart will show. Restart and that’s it.
There have been issues with the December 2008 update. As with all things it’s good to let others trial software updates, and as the increased functionality of any update is not vital, I’m happy to wait until I see reports of problem free updates on the support forum.
Still it is an easy process to follow and good to be able to receive improvements after purchase.
January 7th, 2009 at 6:31 pm
Just to say that I have update my BeBook with the delayed December update, which worked a treat. MobiPocket books look a lot more polished, use a less blocky font and actually retain their intended paragraph formatting.
Nice work from the folk at Endless Ideas – another good reason to get a BeBook – it keeps getting better.
January 26th, 2009 at 5:18 pm
I have just bought a bebook and I couldn’t have made a better choice
First of all – although it looks a bit retro on the pictures (which put me off at first – specially compared to the Sony device) it actually has a kind of rubbery exterior which makes it really nice to hold – so I was pleasantly surprised there.
Second – despite complaints – it reads PDF files just fine – adjust the zoom function to your liking and you’re golden.
And third – and most important for me – is that it reads many formats. I buy most of my books from mobypocket (definitely cheaper that Sony site or Amazon) and my bebook which I ordered from their site http://www.mybebook.com has updated software and reads mobi files nicely.
i hope this was helpful
February 5th, 2009 at 7:14 pm
Given that many users seem to have accidentally zapped their BeBook’s internal memory and wiped all of the default classics which come with their BeBook – and we’ll pass quickly over the fact that the December 2008 Firmware update performed this formatting for many – I have archived the default books in English – plus a few others – and you can download them here.
Please not that this archive is 115MB and that it contains only the following: English PDFs freely available from the BeBook website, copyright free, unaltered and from a Linux PC and so virus free.
February 6th, 2009 at 2:09 pm
Following requests on the BeBook forum here’s a link to the original BeBook manual – in English (sort of)…
February 8th, 2009 at 4:20 pm
I was deleting the other language folders and inadvertently started deleting the English Folder. So would like to get back to the original list.
February 18th, 2009 at 8:40 am
Last week I purchased a new, genuine Nokia BL-5C and an external battery charger and conditioner, from eBay for less than £5. I like the idea of having two batteries and charging them in a dedicated unit rather than through USB which is slower.
The Nokia battery is ever so slightly thicker than the original and so you need to replace the compartment cover carefully.
I have noticed an improvement in the longevity of the Nokia battery, which I charged overnight, compared to the original. I’m most of the way through the 900 or so pages of Darwin’s Origin of species and after that week’s work it is still on 4 segments. So far so good!
February 28th, 2009 at 11:04 am
I have just updated my BeBook to the February 2009 firmware update and retained my PID. This is a relief. As a service to others, I make available the previous firmware updates in case anyone would like to revert to a particular month.
Please note, these are the original firmware files from Endless Ideas, unchanged except I have renamed them to make identification easier as time progresses. Please also note these are large files (40MB) approximately and may take some time to download.
November 2008
January 2009
February 2009
March 12th, 2009 at 8:58 pm
For some excellent BeBook news, check out this post!
April 14th, 2009 at 8:13 pm
You guys seem to be having much more fun with your BeBooks than I am! Bought one for my wife, who reads faster than you can get PDFs across a network
I’ve been trying to make nice-looking PDFs for the BeBook using OpenOffice, but am having trouble with fonts. She wants what some would describe as a stupidly small font — in the end I got some HTML files from Project Gutenberg, but they wouldn’t display properly. Most of the HTML entities are screwed up, e.g. left and right single and double quotes. Feb09 update didn’t fix this. PDFs produced by reading the HTML into OOo and writing them out in a very similar way to the way davidw suggested resulted in huge gaps instead of headings, though the text was readable (if a little clunky). On KPDF, it looked perfect. Examining the supplied PDFs, I found they all used Rockwell font, a commercial font (though you can find free versions of it if you google around).
Resolution: I had to ignore complaints from OOo and just use Rockwell anyway. Also, make all of the headings not bold. OK, but not really a brilliant solution, and I still don’t have a batch-mode way of doing it.
Wouldn’t it be great if zipped HTML files rendered properly, or if some commonly accessible fonts had been used
Some folk tell me that fonts can be added to the font directory at the top level of the device’s internal memory, but I can’t see that folder on my BeBook.
Anybody have any tailorable (pref command-line) solutions for making nice-looking PDFs without resorting to all this font-changing nonsense?
April 16th, 2009 at 10:18 am
Hi Nick,
As I understand it, you’re going from HTML in OOO to PDF with Rockwell. All of the PDFs, I’ve made from OOO have been with standard M$ web fonts, which seem to have been rendered okay.
You may have more luck with Rockwell if you add it to the fonts directory on your SD card or internal memory. All you need to do is create a directory when the reader or SD card is connected to your computer. Make sure it is simply named “fonts” and place the TTF fonts you want to be able to use in their. You would then need to use the reader’s settings menu to change the display font to your choice.
Good luck.
April 30th, 2009 at 10:46 pm
News of a new BeBook eBook reader – this one for only £135!
May 27th, 2009 at 12:04 am
My BeBook review – submitted to Amazon UK
I’ve used a BeBook for 8 months. I nearly didn’t keep it as my first one lasted a week before the off/on button broke and fell inside the case. The second was dead on arrival. The third worked and continues to work excellently. There was clearly an issue with quality control but the support staff at BeBook were helpful during this rather sorry start
My advice to potential purchasers would be research this product, other readers and eBook sites. The market is developing and there are many formats available. The BeBook can read nearly all open or free file formats but at the time of writing (May 2009) the only protected format is MobiPocket. The market has not yet reached the maturity and ease of use that music has with iTunes, so equip yourself with knowledge and research to obtain the most from your reader.
I use a 2GB SD card to store my books. Using this with a cheap USB SD card reader makes for fast and trouble free transfers from my computer to BeBook.
Using PDFs, Mobi, text and HTML files, I have never seen the BeBook forget what page you were on. With the latest firmware, depending on the file format you use, there are more than three zoom levels. You can also load additional fonts to an SD card and thereby change the look and feel of your book. This will be of assistance for the visually impaired.
I like the fact that the BeBook’s firmware is regularly updated, as the product is developed and the users’ needs’ are met. Try getting Sony to act on its users’ suggestions.
The e-Ink screen is beautifully clear and not at all a strain on the eyes. I’ve read my BeBook on the train for instance, with bright sunlight streaming through the windows without a problem. My iPod Touch was unusable in the same conditions.
The battery life is good, although the quoted 7,000 page turns is over-stated. Since I last charged the BeBook four weeks ago, I have read Pride and Prejudice, and skimmed chapters in other books probably totalling some 1,500 page turns and still have two out of four bars showing on the battery. You can use a standard Nokia mobile phone battery as a spare. Charge it in the phone to save time on a USB trickle charge.
I have experienced the occasional crash, usually reading books with tables. The BeBook usually stutters, restarts and takes you back to the page you were reading.
All in all, I’m very pleased with the BeBook. I’m happy with what I can download for free and buy on-line in Mobi format. I’ve knocked off a star due to issues with build quality, but otherwise this is a great eBook reader.
October 19th, 2009 at 7:49 pm
I was wondering if anyone had more info on the Bebook Two. I’ve been wanting to purchase The Bebook and was wondering if it would be worth the wait for the new model.
Thanks
October 22nd, 2009 at 11:25 am
Officially due for release next year. I’d also expect the BB2 to be very expensive when it does become available.
I like the ideas of wi fi and a touch screen, but the overall styling of the device does not appeal. I prefer the square design of the original BeBook.
This video may be of interest from this week’s Frankfurt eBook Fair.